Kids and Cartoons, but in Ragtime
As we have finished reading Ragtime, we talked quite a bit about Tateh. We discussed his motives with his silhouettes and contemplated whether or not he was a sellout. Specifically, on Thursday of last week I believe, we talked about Tateh's final idea for a movie that involved all these little kids of color. Some people in discussion brought up the point that, while the idea was good and new, it did nothing to actually change the social atmosphere.
I wanted to delve more into that idea, because I feel that representation is an incredibly powerful tool, one that I think Tateh realized. While I agree with the profitable portion of his movie makes the motive seem less genuine, the overall message is still good. As a kid growing up in a largely white world, I didn't see a lot of myself or people that looked like me in the media. I remember 2 shows as a kid I could actually relate to, Maya y Miguel (Latinx twins who were smart and sporty) and Dora (everyone knows Dora). As a kid, you absorb everything you watch. I wanted to simultaneously be Phineas, Ferb, Dr. Doofneshmirtz's daughter and the sisters from Johnny Test. The characters we watch as kids influence who we want to be and what we think of ourselves, to some extent. For that reason, Maya y Miguel (because Dora does almost nothing) was incredibly influential to me. As much as I loved watching scooby doo and all the Cartoon Network shows, there was a sense that I could never truly be any of them because for the most part, they were all white and if they had characters of color, they were extremely stereotypical. The power Maya y Miguel had shown me characters who did well in school and were fun to watch made me feel like I could be smart in school and do all the cool things they did. The point was when I saw someone like me doing something, I believed that I too could do that thing.
For this reason, when I read Tateh's final idea, I was so happy. Regardless of the profits he would make, this movie would change a bunch of little kids' lives. For them to see themselves represented, playing with a bunch of other kids who didn't look like them, might make them believe that was possible. In an era where interracial friends were more of a taboo and racism was frequent (not to mention overt), the presence of such a film could inspire kids to change the world, one friendship at a time. I know its really cheesy to think of such a small action having such a large change, but I can't help but think back to child me who was so influenced by the cartoon characters I watched. It's impossible to deny the giant impact media has on society and, in combination with the sponge-like characteristic of kids, ready to absorb information, this movie could have that impact on the kids of the era. Furthermore, because new generations have the ability to change the world in a much more powerful way, having these kids breaking the barriers of race as children can foment a generation of progressive adults. Though this idea reads a bit too much into a ragtime sequel or sort of alternate ending, I can't deny how happy that final movie idea made me.
I wanted to delve more into that idea, because I feel that representation is an incredibly powerful tool, one that I think Tateh realized. While I agree with the profitable portion of his movie makes the motive seem less genuine, the overall message is still good. As a kid growing up in a largely white world, I didn't see a lot of myself or people that looked like me in the media. I remember 2 shows as a kid I could actually relate to, Maya y Miguel (Latinx twins who were smart and sporty) and Dora (everyone knows Dora). As a kid, you absorb everything you watch. I wanted to simultaneously be Phineas, Ferb, Dr. Doofneshmirtz's daughter and the sisters from Johnny Test. The characters we watch as kids influence who we want to be and what we think of ourselves, to some extent. For that reason, Maya y Miguel (because Dora does almost nothing) was incredibly influential to me. As much as I loved watching scooby doo and all the Cartoon Network shows, there was a sense that I could never truly be any of them because for the most part, they were all white and if they had characters of color, they were extremely stereotypical. The power Maya y Miguel had shown me characters who did well in school and were fun to watch made me feel like I could be smart in school and do all the cool things they did. The point was when I saw someone like me doing something, I believed that I too could do that thing.
For this reason, when I read Tateh's final idea, I was so happy. Regardless of the profits he would make, this movie would change a bunch of little kids' lives. For them to see themselves represented, playing with a bunch of other kids who didn't look like them, might make them believe that was possible. In an era where interracial friends were more of a taboo and racism was frequent (not to mention overt), the presence of such a film could inspire kids to change the world, one friendship at a time. I know its really cheesy to think of such a small action having such a large change, but I can't help but think back to child me who was so influenced by the cartoon characters I watched. It's impossible to deny the giant impact media has on society and, in combination with the sponge-like characteristic of kids, ready to absorb information, this movie could have that impact on the kids of the era. Furthermore, because new generations have the ability to change the world in a much more powerful way, having these kids breaking the barriers of race as children can foment a generation of progressive adults. Though this idea reads a bit too much into a ragtime sequel or sort of alternate ending, I can't deny how happy that final movie idea made me.
I could not agree with you more! I really dislike this idea that anything that makes a profit somehow makes it more "impure" or less "wholesome." Popular culture is a for-profit, winner take all, industry. It is also a uniquely important industry, as Pop Culture can shape the norms of younger generations. Consider the rising acceptance of the LGBT community around the world, for example. Straight cisgender teens are exposed to hundreds of extremely famous and proud LBGT people, such as Brendon Urie, Ellen DeGeneres, Lil Nas X, Lil Peep, Kevin Abstract, Tyler the Creator, and Frank Ocean, who they look up to for other reasons, making society as a whole more accepting. LGBT teens have role models to look up to themselves, which makes them feel far less lonely in the past when there was decreased LGBT viability.
ReplyDeleteYou have a really good point here about the importance of representation for kids. I definitely agree that it shouldn't matter if something is for profit if it changes people's perceptions of the world. But I also think that contrasts with our current world, where people seriously think about making movies with minorities of any sort. They worry they'll alienate the mainstream audience, and often end up softening the representation to a point where it may not be as relatable for the people it's supposed to be representing. All of that concern is for profit --- if studios alienate the mainstream audience, they won't get enough profit on their movie, and then all is lost.
ReplyDeleteI never thought of it this way, but I totally agree. I had the idea that Tateh was creating a movie to make money and I didn't think about the actual impact he wanted to/could make. This post makes a good point that yes, even though Tateh could profit from the movie, it's not his primary goal. Also, I think it's cool how you had characters from shows that you looked up to and imagined yourself being like, and I think Tateh had his daughters perspective in mind when coming up with his idea.
ReplyDeleteMy sister and I love Maya & Miguel! I think it's important for there to be media representation of all different races, cultures, sexuality, and gender since it's what people look up to while growing up. I especially thought it was cool since Tateh's final idea could've been really influential during his time period. Little kids from different backgrounds most likely didn't hang out with each other but a film with them hanging out might've been able to influence or change many minds during their time. Idk i just think its a kinda cute happy idea.
ReplyDeleteFirst off I want to agree with Zachary because I like making a profit and I do not see what is wrong with that. In my opinion things that end up being revolutionary like the people who created google and apple deserve to be compensated for their contributions to society (Tateh) . Also knowing the racism was incredibly overt in this age with the second coming of the KKK and how vocal they were about their existence in the 1920s I find myself wondering what the reception of this movie would end up like
ReplyDelete